In horticultural lighting, lifespan isn’t just a technical detail; it’s a key factor influencing costs, efficiency, and crop productivity. For years, High-Pressure Sodium (HPS) bulbs were the standard choice in greenhouses and indoor farms due to their affordability and widespread use. However, with the rise of LED grow lights, growers are rethinking long-term value.

The big question is simple: how long do these lights last? HPS bulbs typically provide 10,000–20,000 hours of usable light before their output and efficiency decline significantly, requiring frequent replacements. This means higher maintenance costs, more labor, and interruptions in growing cycles. LEDs, on the other hand, offer a dramatic advantage with lifespans reaching 50,000 hours or more. Unlike HPS, LEDs maintain consistent light intensity and spectrum over time, reducing replacement frequency and delivering stable growing conditions for crops.

This difference isn’t just about durability; it directly impacts profitability, sustainability, and resource management. By cutting down on energy consumption, minimizing waste, and lowering operating costs, LEDs position themselves as the smarter long-term investment. Ultimately, in the lifespan showdown of HPS vs. LEDs, it’s clear that LEDs aren’t just lasting longer, they’re reshaping the future of efficient, sustainable horticulture.


Understanding Lifespan: Hours on Paper vs. Reality

When manufacturers publish lifespan figures, they aren’t all measured equally.

  • HPS Bulbs (10K–20K hours): While technically capable of lasting up to 20,000 hours, HPS bulbs typically lose efficiency quickly. After just 5,000–10,000 hours, their light output drops significantly, meaning growers either need to tolerate reduced performance or replace them early.

  • LED Fixtures (50K+ hours): LEDs don’t burn out suddenly like HPS. Instead, they gradually lose brightness (a process called lumen depreciation). Most high-quality LEDs maintain 70–90% of their output even after 50,000 hours, making them far more reliable for long-term use.

This difference is crucial: while HPS bulbs may last on paper, their usable lifespan is far shorter compared to LEDs.


Replacement Cycles and Costs

Frequent bulb replacement is one of the hidden costs of using HPS. Let’s break it down:

  • HPS: With a lifespan of 10K–20K hours, a grower operating lights 16 hours per day could expect to replace HPS bulbs every 2–3 years. In large facilities with dozens or hundreds of fixtures, the recurring cost of bulbs, labor, and downtime adds up quickly.

  • LED: At 50K hours, the same grower could run LEDs for 8+ years before reaching significant degradation. That’s a dramatic reduction in replacement frequency, saving not just money but also time and hassle.

When factoring in the full lifespan, LEDs often pay for themselves simply by eliminating the repeated expense of new HPS bulbs.


Light Quality Over Time

Another key factor is how lighting performance changes as fixtures age.

  • HPS Degradation: Even before an HPS bulb “burns out,” it begins losing spectrum stability and brightness. Plants receive less usable light, which can lead to reduced yields, inconsistent growth, and the need to adjust cultivation practices.

  • LED Stability: Quality LEDs are engineered to maintain a stable spectrum over time. That consistency ensures that crops receive the same optimal wavelengths day after day, year after year—critical for predictable harvests.

In other words, LEDs don’t just last longer; they provide better quality light for longer.


Energy Efficiency and Heat Factor

Lifespan isn’t just about how long a bulb glows—it’s also about how efficiently it operates during that time.

  • HPS: Known for running hot, HPS bulbs convert a large portion of electricity into heat rather than usable light. This not only reduces efficiency but also shortens the lifespan of nearby components (ballasts, reflectors, cooling systems).

  • LED: LEDs run cooler and direct more of their energy into photosynthetically active radiation (PAR). Lower heat reduces wear on the fixture itself and helps maintain peak performance for longer.

The cooler operating temperature of LEDs directly contributes to their extended lifespan.


Sustainability Matters

With global agriculture shifting toward eco-conscious practices, sustainability is a key consideration.

  • HPS Waste: Frequent bulb replacements mean more waste, packaging, and shipping. HPS bulbs also contain materials like sodium and mercury, which require careful disposal.

  • LED Longevity: Fewer replacements mean less waste over time. Many LED fixtures are also designed with recyclable components, aligning with sustainable farming goals.

By choosing LEDs, growers can reduce their environmental footprint while also improving operational efficiency.


Real-World Impact: A Simple Example

Let’s consider a 10,000-square-foot indoor farm with 100 lights, running 16 hours per day.

  • HPS (15K-hour average lifespan):

    • Replacement cycle: Every ~2.5 years

    • Total replacements over 10 years: ~4 cycles → 400 bulbs

    • Costs: Bulbs + labor + downtime

  • LED (50K-hour lifespan):

    • Replacement cycle: Every ~8.5 years

    • Total replacements over 10 years: 1 cycle → 100 fixtures

    • Costs: Significantly lower long-term

This simple math shows how quickly the replacement advantage of LEDs translates into major savings.


Why LEDs Are the Clear Winner in Lifespan

Summing it all up:

  1. HPS Lifespan: 10K–20K hours, but with significant degradation along the way.

  2. LED Lifespan: 50K+ hours, with stable output and spectrum.

  3. Maintenance: LEDs drastically reduce replacement cycles and labor costs.

  4. Light Quality: LEDs maintain consistent, crop-optimized performance.

  5. Sustainability: LEDs generate less waste and align with eco-friendly farming.

While HPS technology has served growers well for decades, its shorter lifespan and high replacement costs make it a less practical choice in today’s efficiency-driven agriculture.


Conclusion

In the lifespan face-off between HPS and LED, the numbers don’t lie. HPS bulbs may offer a short-term solution with lower upfront costs, but their 10K–20K hour lifespan, coupled with rapid degradation, makes them costly and inefficient over time.

LEDs, with their 50K-hour (and beyond) durability, not only outlast HPS by years but also provide consistent light quality, energy savings, and reduced maintenance. For growers focused on long-term success, scalability, and sustainability, LEDs aren’t just the future—they’re the smart choice right now.